Writing as a thinking tool

412 points · 100 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

Without writing, humans are reduced to finite automata; writing externalizes thinking.

The author argues writing is an out-of-core execution mechanism that externalizes thinking, turning the brain from a finite automaton into a Turing machine. Drawing on Manuel Blum's advice and his own experience with mind maps, he says writing forces slower, deeper processing, revealing connections missed by initial reading. He warns that LLMs produce plausible text without real thinking, making manual writing a comparative advantage. His rules: produce a messy first draft freely, then edit ruthlessly, keep prose simple, write for yourself, and schedule writing regularly.

What commenters are saying

Commenters broadly agree that writing, especially by hand, is essential for thinking. Many share systems: A4 5mm grid pads and colored ballpoints for designing systems, or fountain pens and fineliners with color-coded symbols for notes. A subthread discusses the value of handwriting over digital tools. Several commenters note that AI writing shortcuts the thinking process, making it hard to trust the author's depth. One warns that using AI to reply to feedback undermines genuine engagement.