We're Asking an Appeals Court to Require a Warrant for ALPR Searches
Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.
EFF and ACLU argue that warrantless ALPR searches violate the Fourth Amendment.
EFF and the ACLU filed an amicus brief in United States v. Sturdivant at the Sixth Circuit. Police used Flock and ELSAG ALPR databases without a warrant to track a suspect's car and link it to robberies. A lower court ruled that drivers have no reasonable expectation of privacy in visible license plates. EFF argues ALPRs enable mass surveillance and constitute a Fourth Amendment search, citing a recent federal ruling that ALPRs are a form of indiscriminate mass surveillance.
What commenters are saying
Most commenters agree with EFF that ALPR searches should require a warrant. Many argue the law should go further: some suggest ALPRs should only store hits on plates under active warrant, others call for deletion of non-hit data within minutes (citing New Hampshire law). A minority notes that historical ALPR data can be useful for solving serious crimes or rescues. Skeptics argue that even strong regulation won't prevent abuse, and that cameras should not exist in communities without consent.