We need smart people who give a shit

690 points · 345 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

Complex systems rely on smart people who give a shit, and they are being replaced by generative AI.

The author argues that fragile systems like ACH work only because of smart, dedicated people who manually patch flaws. Generative AI lacks the care and deep system knowledge needed to maintain critical infrastructure. Recent failures at Microsoft 365, air traffic control, United Airlines, the NSA, banks, and Apple are linked to a shortage of such people. Capitalism drives layoffs of these workers in favor of cheaper AI, eroding the ownership and struggle that made them effective. The author calls this a "hot stove moment" for capitalism.

What commenters are saying

Commenters broadly agree with the article's premise. Top comments argue that companies undervalue technical work by adding project management responsibilities to engineers, preventing specialization and system expertise. Some push back, saying taking ownership of the full lifecycle is part of professionalism. Others note that management offloads its duties onto engineers, and that smart people are often treated poorly. One commenter suggests executives should face annual firings for bad decisions. A minority argues LLMs exemplify "smart and gets things done," which is why CEOs embrace them.