US Government is hiding a secret court ruling about how it spies on Americans
Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.
The Trump administration is accused of illegally withholding a FISA court ruling on surveillance.
Two Democratic senators, Ron Wyden and Adam Schiff, say the Trump administration is breaking the law by withholding a Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court ruling. The March 2026 ruling found that filtering tools used to read Americans' messages amount to searches subject to legal limits. The administration's own policy requires public release within 180 days, a deadline that passed in September. The ruling remains secret as the administration pushes Congress to reauthorize Section 702 of FISA, which lapsed in June but continues under court approval. A coalition of civil liberties groups is urging Congress to refuse reauthorization until the ruling is released.
What commenters are saying
Commenters broadly condemn secret courts as antithetical to democracy, citing the Star Chamber and the 6th Amendment. Several argue the FISA court provides no legitimacy and should be abolished. A split emerges: some claim both parties support spying on Americans, while others note Wyden is a Democrat raising the issue. One commenter argues the US constitution is effectively dead. Another quotes Milton Mayer on habituation to government secrecy. Some debate whether secrecy is inherently anti-democratic.