UK Green party drops longstanding opposition to nuclear power

215 points · 276 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

The UK Green Party votes to end blanket opposition to nuclear power, allowing case-by-case support.

Green party members in England and Wales voted to drop a longstanding commitment to phase out nuclear fission, replacing it with a policy that assesses nuclear projects alongside other low-carbon technologies. The motion allows elected representatives to support new reactors on a case-by-case basis while prioritizing offshore wind, onshore wind, and rooftop solar. MP Carla Denyer said existing nuclear stations could be kept running as a low-carbon option during the transition to renewables, though she had previously called nuclear "incredibly slow and incredibly expensive." The policy shift was motivated by climate urgency and energy security concerns.

What commenters are saying

Commenters largely welcome the shift but argue it came decades too late, blaming past opposition on Cold War-era fears and fossil fuel lobbying. A split emerges: some argue nuclear is the only viable baseload complement to renewables, while others contend it remains too expensive and slow compared to solar and storage. Several point out France's success with nuclear and criticize Germany's shutdown of plants as a strategic error that enabled Russian energy leverage. A few note the change reflects generational replacement of anti-nuclear activists rather than reasoned persuasion.