Tesla Hasn't Had a Successful New Product Launch Since JB Straubel Stepped Down

200 points · 272 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

Tesla has not launched a successful major product since JB Straubel left as CTO in July 2019.

The Cybertruck was a $2 billion net loss, selling 70k units over three years against tooling for 125k/year. The Model Y was Straubel's last major project. Since his departure, Tesla has only launched the failing Cybertruck and the Cybercab. Straubel may have moderated Musk's unrealistic ambitions, preventing products like the Cybertruck with half the promised range and double the price.

What commenters are saying

Commenters split into two camps. One argues Tesla is now a battery and energy company, not a car company, while others see it as a speculative narrative play where Musk maintains stock price through hype. Multiple commenters note Tesla's market cap (~$1.4T) is roughly 4.6x Toyota's despite generating 10% of Toyota's profits. Some claim Tesla gave up being a car company years ago; others point to autonomous driving and Optimus as the real valuation drivers.