Smart home devices should work without the internet

1073 points · 382 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

After ten years, the author's core rule is that no smart home device should depend on a vendor's server.

The author's home automation setup uses Tasmota on ESP boards, an MQTT broker, and Node-RED on a Raspberry Pi, with core functions like lights and garage door working entirely offline. Alexa is used only as an optional interface. The post includes 11 rules developed over a decade, such as "no batteries unless they last a year" and "config lives in one place." Two talks are presented slide by slide, covering builds including a sprinkler controller, garage door sensor with Grafana charts, and a wall-mounted tablet dashboard that replaced five vendor apps.

What commenters are saying

Commenters largely agreed with the author's local-first philosophy. Several shared their own stricter rules, such as requiring physical controls to work without any network or automation server. One commenter noted Zigbee allows direct device-to-device pairing, so basic functionality survives even if the controller is down. Others complained about internet-dependent appliances like smart fridges with certificate errors and internet radios that stop working when their servers shut down. A few pointed out that Alexa routines technically violate the author's own rule, but the author defended this as acceptable because core systems remain controllable offline.