Quad9 to exit France

1281 points · 432 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

Quad9 will withdraw DNS services from France on Nov 24, 2026, citing an untenable court order to block piracy-related domains.

A French court ruled that Quad9 must block DNS resolution for domain names linked to copyright infringement of beIN sports broadcasts, reducing a daily penalty from €580,000 to €1,000. Quad9, a Swiss nonprofit, says compliance is technically impossible without geoIP blocking, which failed in a prior German case (Sony) and would force French law globally. Unable to reliably identify French users or block via VPN-circumventable methods, Quad9 will exit France on November 24. Twenty other similar cases are pending. The company argues DNS blocking is ineffective against piracy and harms cybersecurity for millions.

What commenters are saying

Commenters largely criticized the court's reasoning, comparing DNS resolvers to phone books or infrastructure providers that should not be liable for third-party content. One comment noted that Sony used a VPN to bypass geoIP blocking, leading to Quad9 being fined for contempt, highlighting the absurdity of expecting perfect enforcement. Another pointed out that the €1,000/day penalty is manageable for a nonprofit, but with 20 other pending cases the cumulative risk is existential. Several argued that copyright enforcement should target content hosts, not neutral intermediaries.