Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine
Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.
Quad9 withdraws its free DNS resolver from France after a court ordered it to block copyright-infringing domains.
A French court imposed daily fines on Quad9 for failing to block domains linked to copyright infringement, forcing the Swiss non-profit to either comply and undermine user privacy or withdraw from France. Quad9 chose withdrawal, disrupting users including hospitals, schools, and government bodies who rely on the resolver. Cloudflare argues DNS blocking is ineffective, easily bypassed, and causes collateral damage, warning that similar orders in Belgium threaten Cloudflare, Google, and Cisco. Cloudflare advocates targeting hosting providers instead.
Cisco previously withdrew OpenDNS from France under similar orders. Cloudflare successfully fought a French ruling against DNS blocking but faces a Belgian order requiring blocking by January 2027.
What commenters are saying
Many commenters see Quad9's withdrawal as symptomatic of the internet's fragmentation into nation-level networks, a process they argue began decades ago with China's Great Firewall and US crypto export controls. Some contend the 'free global internet' never truly existed outside American hegemony. Others criticize European overregulation and question Cloudflare's selective outrage, noting it blocks entire countries via its security firewall.
A split emerges: some say copyright must be addressed to preserve the internet, while others argue copyright is dead and business models must adapt to digital reality. Commenters also point out that AI companies face minimal copyright consequences.