Python's experimental JIT to be removed

545 points · 298 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

Python's experimental JIT compiler is being removed from CPython after PEP 836 was withdrawn.

The experimental JIT compiler added to CPython in 2024 for Python 3.13 is being removed after its maintainers withdrew PEP 836. The Python steering council had requested a standards-track PEP addressing maintenance, compatibility, and success metrics. After months of discussion, the PEP authors cited insufficient personal bandwidth to carry the proposal forward. The steering council's September statement said the PEP answered its questions but lacked specificity on support plans, performance criteria, platform parity, user impact, security, and compatibility timelines. The JIT will be removed from CPython's main branch during the Python 3.16 development cycle.

What commenters are saying

Commenters are split between those who see the JIT's removal as a loss for Python performance and those who view the steering council's process as necessary caution. Some express frustration with what they call bureaucratic overhead discouraging ambitious contributions, while others argue the council's requirements were reasonable for a feature with broad ecosystem impact. Several commenters note that earlier JIT efforts (Unladen Swallow, PyPy) also failed to gain upstream traction. One technical comment argues that any successful Python JIT must first implement a hidden type model for optimizing property access, a hard problem that the current effort did not convincingly address.