Position: LLMs Can't Jump
Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.
LLMs lack the grounded sensory experience needed for creative leaps in science.
The article is a CAPTCHA wall blocking access to an OpenReview forum entry. No article content is available.
What commenters are saying
Commenters debated whether LLMs can make intuitive leaps like humans. Some argued sensory grounding is essential for breakthroughs such as Einstein's relativity. Others countered that abstract fields like math require similar grounding. One user noted prior HN discussions on identical headlines. A proposal to train an LLM on pre-1980 text to see if it could bootstrap itself generated extensive back-and-forth, with objections about data leakage, model collapse, and the need for modern hardware.