Nintendo Takes Down Emulators and Firmware in Massive GitHub DMCA Sweep

313 points · 246 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

Article body wasn't reachable. The HN discussion summary is below.

What commenters are saying

Commenters largely derided Nintendo's aggressive legal tactics and debated how to host emulators without being found. Several argued that hosting on platforms like Forgejo or Gitlab on offshore servers paid with crypto makes it nearly impossible for Nintendo to act. Others noted that emulators themselves lack circumvention code, but Nintendo relies on the argument that emulators require decryption keys, which qualifies as circumvention devices under DMCA Section 1201. One commenter claimed that the same legal rationale used against emulators has been inconsistently applied, enabling billion-dollar AI companies to avoid liability while ordinary users face severe penalties.

A subthread discussed running a Radicle node over Tor as a censorship-resistant alternative, while another argued that the key is anonymity and jurisdiction, not the hosting platform.