Monkey Island: all 13 versions side by side

488 points · 155 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

A site lets you compare 13 versions of The Secret of Monkey Island side by side.

The site, built by two brothers calling themselves The Paninos off-line, captures the same 12 moments from the game across 13 versions released between 1990 and 1993, including PC (EGA, CGA, VGA, Hercules), Amiga, Atari ST, Macintosh, FM Towns, and Sega CD editions. Each screen was captured at 1600x1200 with nearest-neighbour scaling and 4:3 aspect correction in ScummVM (or Hatari for Atari ST mono). A CRT shader from DOSBox Staging is optional. The site notes that only two real sets of artwork exist (EGA and VGA); other versions dither or reduce those.

What commenters are saying

Commenters praised the site's UX and mobile friendliness. Several noted that only two sets of original artwork exist (EGA and VGA); other versions are dithers or reductions. One commenter pointed out that the anniversary re-release is missing. Several shared nostalgia for specific graphics modes: CGA's cyan-magenta palette felt cold to some, while EGA/VGA felt warm. A few highlighted the music differences across sound chips and CD audio, with links to YouTube comparisons. One commenter corrected the site's labeling of CGA as "16-color" since CGA could only display 4 colors at once at this resolution, though another noted composite monitors could show more.