Jepsen: ParticleDB 1.1.4

290 points · 165 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

Jepsen found 96 issues in ParticleDB, including data loss and transactional anomalies.

Jepsen tested ParticleDB versions 1.1.4 through 1.1.18.11.rc-22, finding 96 issues including crashes, deadlocks, data loss, partially-invisible rows, and internal anomalies. By version 1.1.18.11.rc-22, all but ten issues appeared resolved, but ParticleDB continued to lose committed writes during normal operation with the default occ transaction mode and allowed lost updates with serializable. The research was funded by Orkes, makers of ParticleDB, who claimed version 1.1.19-rc.13 resolves all remaining issues.

What commenters are saying

Commenters were highly critical, with many characterizing ParticleDB as a "slop DB" or "vibe-coded" database written in Rust. Some argued the extent of bugs suggests fundamental engineering failures, not just pre-release issues. A ParticleDB team member responded that they took findings seriously, spent months fixing issues, and now run daily Jepsen tests alongside agentic testing, though skepticism remained high about the depth of fixes. Several noted the irony of a database claiming formal verification while exhibiting such basic failures.