ID.me terms required for IRS sign-in

408 points · 203 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

IRS sign-in via ID.me subjects taxpayers to mandatory arbitration and marketing data use.

Taxpayers using ID.me to access IRS online services must accept private terms including forced arbitration (opt-out within 30 days), a $1,000 liability cap, and data use for marketing. ID.me's privacy policy allows sharing information in corporate transactions and retaining data up to three years after account deletion. The IRS also accepts Login.gov, a government-run alternative, but critics note ID.me replaced traditional login on TreasuryDirect in October 2026. Senators Wyden and Warren have questioned the continued reliance on ID.me over Login.gov.

What commenters are saying

Commenters broadly criticize requiring a private, for-profit intermediary to access government services, with many noting Login.gov as a less intrusive alternative. Several users recount experiences with ID.me's verification process and data retention concerns. One commenter sold TreasuryDirect bonds early to avoid ID.me. A thread highlights that IRS launched Login.gov integration only two weeks ago after five years of work. Another user points out the absurdity of needing biometric verification for online tax access when paper filings require no such steps.