I wish tech companies knew more about me
Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.
A user argues that despite pervasive tracking, tech platforms fail to deliver useful personalization or relevant ads.
The author shares multiple examples of tracking failures: seeing ads for recently purchased items, Spotify not filtering out disliked vocal tracks despite years of skips, Google showing a Finnish-language page despite English settings, and PlayStation store resetting language preferences. They also note irrelevant ads (3D printing resin, Helsinki hotels, asphalt cleaning tractor), YouTube recommending random ovens after a specific appliance search, and Netflix requiring user selection for a single-user account. The author concludes that companies collect data but don't effectively use it.
What commenters are saying
Commenters split into two camps: those who see the article as naive about ad targeting's incentives, and those who argue the problem is structural. Top comments note that advertisers don't need ultra-precise targeting, as showing irrelevant ads has little cost. A commenter working in ads targeting counters that the systems are highly complex and have driven double-digit revenue growth at Google, Meta, and TikTok. Another observes that Instagram's ads feel more relevant than Google's, possibly because they target social niche identity rather than purchase history. One commenter questions the ethics of building psychological profiling models at scale.