I saw your HN comment

431 points · 323 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

LLMs enable deceptive product pitches disguised as genuine interest in HN comments.

Josh Strange reports that emails about his HN comments shifted from mostly signal (2013-2021) to mostly pitches (88% in 2026). LLMs let senders write personalized, deceptive emails posing open-ended questions to elicit detailed replies, then pivot to selling a product/service. He finds this growth hacking disgusting and now distrusts all outreach, treating people as guilty until proven innocent. He keeps his email public hoping for serendipity, but says the internet he misses may not return.

What commenters are saying

Commenters overwhelmingly share the experience: LLM-generated spam is drowning out genuine human interaction on HN. Many have removed their email from profiles or auto-sorted HN mentions to spam. Some propose filters like karma thresholds or username-in-subject templates. A few note that in-person relationships remain unharmed. One commenter observes that while SSH scan volume dropped, targeted AI phishing for community-specific data has increased.