I don't understand quantum physics (2018)

336 points · 262 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

Quantum physics is fundamentally counterintuitive and cannot be fully grasped through classical analogies.

Douglas Ross, a professor at Southampton University, wrote an accessible guide to quantum physics for the interested layman. The article covers classical physics, key experiments, wave-particle duality, matter waves, Heisenberg's uncertainty principle, wavefunctions, quantum tunneling, superposition, two-state systems, wavefunction collapse, interpretations of quantum mechanics, thought experiments, hidden variables, and probabilistic determinism. It includes a glossary, mathematical formulae, and references. The full text is available as a PDF.

What commenters are saying

Commenters largely agreed that quantum physics is deeply non-intuitive, with many citing Feynman's quote that nobody truly understands it. A major discussion focused on hidden variable theories and Bell's inequality. One camp argued local hidden variables are ruled out by Bell tests, while others pointed to superdeterminism or retrocausality as loopholes that preserve local hidden variables, though these are widely considered weirder than standard QM. Several commenters noted that entanglement cannot transmit information faster than light due to the no-communication theorem.