Humans will never again create a project quite like Wikipedia

480 points · 432 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

Wikipedia may be the last encyclopedia built solely by human contributors, argues a new book.

Richard Cooke's book, 'The Last Best Place on the Internet,' argues Wikipedia is the largest human-written encyclopedia and likely the last. It faces existential threats: a 33% decline in active English editors since 2007, a quarter of its readership lost since 2022, and AI's absorption of its content. AI LLMs trained on Wikipedia now draw only 0.33% clickthrough rates, reducing donations and recruitment. The article notes Wikipedia's origins as a crowd-sourced project from Nupedia, its early growth due to low quality inviting improvement, and challenges from culture wars and a tightening of editing rules.

What commenters are saying

Commenters split into two camps: those agreeing that the social and political challenges make a repeat impossible, and those pointing to existing crowd-sourced projects like OpenStreetMap and TV Tropes as counterexamples. One thread highlights that the challenge is not technical but social-no one would contribute to an empty clone. Others note that AI has made it harder to ensure human-only contributions, and some argue that good AI contributions are better than human trolling, though AI also risks overwhelming curation with infinite spam.