Guerrilla bike lanes: San Francisco makes illicit infrastructure permanent (2016)

323 points · 249 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

San Francisco made guerrilla bike lanes official after activists installed them illegally.

After two cyclists were killed in hit-and-run collisions near Golden Gate Park, the anonymous San Francisco Transformation Agency (SFMTrA) installed protected bike lanes using traffic cones and soft-hit posts. The city initially said it had to remove unauthorized objects but instead left them in place and plans to install official safe hit posts. Similar efforts in Seattle and New York have had mixed results. Seattle initially removed posts but later reinstalled them; New York activists painted an entire lane after a local board rejected an extension.

What commenters are saying

The thread broadly supports the idea of guerrilla bike lanes, viewing them as direct action that bypasses slow, costly bureaucracy. Several commenters argue that overly cautious planning processes and fear of litigation are the real failures, not the activists. Examples of similar civic hacking include guerrilla gardening and an artist who fixed a freeway sign, which Caltrans later made official. A cautionary counterexample is noted: people in LA have put up fake no-parking signs to protect private parking, leading to real tickets.