Geoffrey Hinton: it might turn out we were better off without AI

313 points · 306 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

Geoffrey Hinton warns humanity might have been better off without developing AI.

Nobel-winning AI pioneer Geoffrey Hinton warns that AI could trigger a large-scale incident this year or next, such as a blackout of financial or power systems. He says within a decade we'll know if risks can be managed safely or if society faces massive inequality and unemployment. Hinton says he doesn't trust OpenAI's Sam Altman, and criticizes Mark Zuckerberg and Elon Musk for prioritizing profit over safety. He calls for mandatory independent testing of frontier AI models, similar to FDA drug approval. Despite warnings, he remains cautiously hopeful catastrophe can be averted.

What commenters are saying

Commenters are deeply skeptical of AI's benefits, with many arguing it creates more problems than it solves. One commenter details how AI has reduced free time: extra effort to find AI-free content, hallucinated answers from professionals, bloated software updates, and frustrating customer service bots. Another notes that people only respond to immediate crises, suggesting a major AI-caused outage might force society to reconsider unchecked development, though others counter that such events would cause real harm and death. A few dismiss Hinton as left behind by the field.