Every Mac comes with an (undocumented) family member classifier

767 points · 416 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

Every Mac since 2022 runs undocumented daemons building a personal knowledge graph.

Two daemons, knowledgeconstructiond and intelligenceplatformd, construct a local knowledge graph in ~/Library/IntelligencePlatform, stored in 51 SQLite databases. The graph uses 181 entity classes and 278 predicates, inferring relationships from Contacts, Calendar, Photos, Messages, Mail, location, Screen Time, and more. It includes inferred kinship, employer, and activity types. The researchers open-sourced a dashboard (iKnow) to inspect the graph and warn it could be exploited if LLMs query it, creating a privacy single point of failure.

What commenters are saying

Commenters expressed alarm and anger over undocumented data collection. Some noted the graph stays local (TCC-protected) but can be queried by Apple Intelligence, raising prompt injection risks. A German commenter argued it violates TDDDG §25 (storage without consent). Two camps emerged: those who find on-device processing acceptable and those who see it as spyware. Several confirmed the graph exists on Sequoia and Sonoma. Others criticized the article for heavy LLM-generated prose, finding it hard to read.