Emacs in the Age of Magic
Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.
AI tools let anyone reimplement full app stacks in Emacs Lisp with trivial effort.
The article explores how AI code generation has upended Emacs culture, where customizability was once a key advantage. It cites two case studies: excali-mode (reimplementing Excalidraw's entire stack for the Emacs canvas API) and cooked.el (building a full Rust terminal emulator for Emacs). The author argues that traditional notions of wastefulness vanish when building and tearing down software costs only token fees. He notes that AI has inverted Stallman's software freedom goal: users can now make any imaginable tool work, but no one understands how it functions.
The piece draws a historical arc from punch cards to Lisp to modern AI, observing that each era's programming constraints shaped what developers considered possible. The conclusion suggests that AI may soon write directly to hardware, translating high-level intent into machine code as nature translated DNA into life.
What commenters are saying
Commenters split sharply. Enthusiasts see unlimited potential and compare AI to having a "butler" for coding, while skeptics warn of "professional brainrot" and loss of understanding. One critic argued deterministic tooling remains essential because AI-built apps are "thin little bumps" on a mountain of hard-coded infrastructure, and that widespread "vibe coding" would collapse the stack. Another noted that even Linux kernel bugs now come from AI-written code. A minor thread debated whether Neomacs crashes demonstrated the dangers of unsupervised AI development.