DNS resolvers are the wrong place to fight piracy

669 points · 274 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

Quad9 is leaving France due to court orders requiring DNS-level piracy blocking.

Quad9, a Swiss non-profit DNS resolver, will stop serving France on November 24, 2026, after a Paris court fined it €1,000/day for refusing to block pirate sports-streaming domains for beIN Sports. The court used Quad9's malware filtering as precedent that it could block domains. With ~20 similar cases pending, Quad9 says compliance costs are existential. Cloudflare called the departure 'a canary in the coal mine.' The article argues DNS blocking is ineffective (easily bypassed, can't geolocate reliably), causes collateral damage (citing Italy's Piracy Shield blocking Google Drive), and sets a precedent for global censorship.

Quad9's options-block globally, geo-block, or fight-are all untenable: global blocking imposes French law worldwide, geo-blocking failed in Germany, and litigation costs are prohibitive.

What commenters are saying

Top commenters split sharply. One camp argued Quad9's malware filtering undermined its 'common carrier' defense, proving it can censor domains. Another camp saw this as government overreach via civil court, with one commenter noting 'judges and lawmakers did this because they got paid.' Several pointed out the irony of an AI-written piece asking for 'well-reasoned' arguments. A technical critique noted that a self-hosted recursive resolver avoids the problem entirely. Some dismissed the whole fight, saying piracy enforcement is futile and DNS blocking only inconveniences non-technical users.