CNC Stone Carving

496 points · 137 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

Monks use CNC machines to carve intricate Gothic stonework efficiently.

The Carmelite Monks use Prussiani Engineering CNC machines (5-axis, diamond-tipped) to carve Gothic church elements like pinnacles, statues, and gargoyles. A digital workflow involves 3D modeling in Mudbox, CAM toolpath programming, and sawyers operating the machines. The process reduces carving time from months to days, enabling ornate details despite lack of traditional stonemasonry skills. The monks argue this continues medieval builders' tradition of adopting cutting-edge technology. Their monastery construction spans decades, using CNC for complex pieces while simpler cuts use wire saws.

What commenters are saying

Commenters largely admire the project, with some noting the monks also run Mystic Monk Coffee. A significant debate emerges: several argue the lengthy hand-carving process was intrinsic to Gothic cathedrals' spiritual meaning, representing devotion and sacrifice. Others counter that the monks still undertake a multi-decade endeavor relative to their small community, and that medieval builders would have used CNCs if available. References include Barry X Ball's stone carving and the Guédelon Castle project in France building a medieval castle with period tools.