Cartographers of North Korea (2019)

291 points · 58 comments on HN · read original →

Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.

OpenStreetMap contributors explain why they map North Korea.

The article collects responses from 211 OpenStreetMap contributors who mapped North Korea. Motivations include: filling a blank map for relaxation, political idealism (hoping for reunification or aiding future aid), as an act of defiance against censorship, and fascination with a closed country. Contributors typically traced satellite imagery (Bing/DigitalGlobe) from abroad, as North Koreans lack internet access. Several contributors refute the idea that the work is state-led, citing low node counts and hobbyist patterns. One contributor from Germany draws parallels to Cold War East Germany.

What commenters are saying

Commenters praised the site's design and the contributor stories. One noted that vandalism on OSM appears rare. Another listed OSM among their "7 Wonders of the Internet" alongside Wikipedia and archive.org. A few commenters shared that North Korean border officers check tourists' cameras and may demand photo deletions. Some pushed back on the idea that tourist videos show real life, arguing that escapee accounts describe a far worse reality. A debate emerged about whether Pyongyang's relative wealth suggests an upper class, versus the broader population's suffering.