AI is a tool and using it well takes skill
Points and comments are a snapshot, not live.
LLMs are tools that require skill to wield effectively.
The author argues that LLMs fit the definition of tools despite Rich Hickey's claim they are automation. Tools like saws and spreadsheets require operator skill, and LLMs similarly depend on user judgment, intent, and feedback loops. Expertise improves outcomes, and unpredictability does not disqualify something as a tool. The author criticizes anthropomorphic language about AI, favoring a focus on skilled use versus delegation without oversight.
What commenters are saying
Commenters split between viewing LLMs as tools requiring skill versus marketing-driven framing. One camp notes that domain expertise remains essential for effective use, especially in scaling applications. Several agree that clear communication of intent is the most future-proof skill. Some argue that specific prompting techniques become obsolete quickly, making deep investment in workflows risky. A minority point out that many users still lack basic proficiency, similar to Google Search literacy.